5.0 out of 5 stars Nice, not perfect, but no 4.5 rating available For anyone considering the jacket as a purchase here are the points I would mention beforehand:First keep in mind its a “light” design – sort of fashionable outerwear, nothing heavy to protect you against harsh weather or to wear in the winter if you are in a region that gets snow and cold.Second, I ordered the “brown” color and onscreen the color isn’t quite what you get. Its a deeper brown with a sort of yellowish-red tint to it. That’s not bad perse, probably actually a better color than what is pictured which is more of a flat milk-chocolate type of brown.Third, a lot of questions have been asked about the size so here’s what I found: I am 5 foot 11 inches and about 190 pounds. I originally ordered the extra large then cancelled that before it came when I reread the chest and waist measurements and got the large instead. The large is about an inch or less bigger at the chest, so a pretty good match, and a tighter fit at the waist (I am about 15-20 pounds overweight). So I expected it to be tighter at the waist.Overall for my size and height, wearing just a t-shirt underneath the jacket, its a good fit. Anything else underneath like a sweater or sweatshirt would make it too tight of a fit. So if your measurements are anywhere near mine and you intend to wear it in a fashion sense, just get a large. If you are thinking of it in terms of more of a weather type autumn/winter outerwear in maybe a milder climate than northern extremes, get the extra large.All in all a good jacket for the price.Two other points I would mention that I think gives this a 4.5. Not that they could do much about this, but the zipper down the front sticks a bit, and especially at the end it can be hard to get it started or separate the two ends. Also, the collar is hard to fold down and keep it staying down (which is hard with anything really that has a thick upper collar, but keep that in mind if you are thinking about wearing this with the collar down). I expect with some wear that would be less of a problem. 15 people found this helpful
